Chris Minns made an interesting announcement this morning, revealing that Labor’s candidate for Epping will be Tanya Raffoul, the councillor for the Dundas ward of the City of Parramatta (my local ward), who was elected as a Liberal in 2024 before leaving the party and voting for a Labor mayor in September.
This is a fascinating move which I think says more about Labor than it does about the Liberal Party, and about how Labor is responding to realignments taking shape in Australian politics.
The seat of Epping lies on the edge of northern and western Sydney, mostly lying in the City of Parramatta along with the southern tip of Hornsby Shire. The seat has been held by the Liberal Party since its creation in 1999. It was traditionally a safe Liberal seat but the gap between Epping and the state has been shrinking. In 2003, the Liberal Party did 13.1% better in Epping than the state overall, while that gap was 9.1% in 2023.
In 2023, Labor candidate Alan Mascarenhas ran an energetic campaign while the sitting MP Dominic Perrottet was busy leading the government, and managed to cut the margin down to 4.8%. But Labor chose not to run in the subsequent 2024 by-election, and Monica Tudehope won the seat by a 19.2% margin over the Greens.
Since 2024, however, the political map has obviously changed.
We don’t yet have any sub-state polling, and it would be great if we could get an MRP of New South Wales state polling to give us a sense of what is going on. But information is leaking out of the parties, and their decisions tell us a bit about their hopes and fears.
One Nation appears to be a serious threat to Labor in outer suburban seats like Penrith, Camden and Cessnock. While Labor should benefit from preferences between the Coalition and One Nation exhausting, their primary vote is also very low now – Labor is now regularly polling 29-30%, compared to 37% in 2023.
If Labor is in serious danger of losing some of their seats, Labor’s path back to government, and possibly into majority, relies on finding other seats to pick up elsewhere.
Hence Epping.
Recently I wrote a brief for my other job listing different kinds of electoral contests at the NSW election, and I identified Epping, along with a number of other seats, as Liberal seats where Labor has potential to pick them up.
The list includes Winston Hills, Ryde, Lane Cove, Miranda and Oatley. Four of these six seats lie in a row, stretching around the north of Parramatta deep into the north shore. The other two are also next to each other in southern Sydney.
Some of these seats are ones that Labor has won in the past, but Epping and Lane Cove are something else.
These seats coming into play is consistent with the collapse in Coalition support across the north shore over the last four years. While the teals have grabbed the attention, taking federal and state seats, Labor has been making advances in the north-west as well.
Labor and the Greens have done quite well in Lane Cove council, and federal Labor MP Jerome Laxale now represents Lane Cove and Hunters Hill in his electorate of Bennelong. Laxale polled substantial 2PP majorities across Lane Cove in 2025 and even won a booth in Hunters Hill.
Parramatta federal MP Andrew Charlton has quite substantial 2PP margins in the Carlingford area (contained in the state seat of Epping) and Labor came within two points of winning the seat of Berowra in 2025 – Labor actually polled over 60% of the 2PP in all of the Epping-area booths that year.
These voting trends suggest Labor could be a serious threat in Lane Cove and Epping, particularly if One Nation takes some of the Liberal vote and those voters then exhaust their preferences. The seat of Ryde was already extremely close, so if Labor is putting more effort into Epping it suggests a level of confidence about that neighbouring seat.
Labor is also clearly hoping to scare some of those Liberal voters into the Labor camp with talk of the Liberal Party and One Nation working together. This was a major focus of Tanya Raffoul’s speech at the press conference, trying to tie her former party to One Nation.
Raffoul is an interesting figure – quite a substantial part of her ward lies within the neighbouring electorate of Parramatta, and she was announced this morning at Oatlands Public School, mere metres from the electorate boundary.
But Raffoul is Lebanese, and Oatlands contains a very large Lebanese community, who have reliably voted for the Liberal party. Looking at this electoral map of Epping, Oatlands stands out as bright blue in a sea of red.
Generally, the Liberal Party won the booths in the northern end of the electorate and Labor won in the south (which produced a Liberal win once their lead in the pre-poll is factored in).
But the two booths in Oatlands were the most pro-Liberal in the entire electorate, with 66% and 71% of the two-party-preferred vote.
This is not unique to the 2023 state election – it can also be seen in state and federal results. At the 2025 federal election, the two Oatlands booths were the only election day booths not won by Andrew Charlton.
The decline in support for the Coalition in northern Sydney has been an ongoing story, but I think today’s news says a lot more about Labor, and the Minns government.
The choice to welcome a Liberal defector into the party and preselect her for a potentially winnable seat is something that would have traditionally been unthinkable for Labor.
There is a long history of Labor members defecting and ending up on the conservative side of politics – three conservative prime ministers started out as Labor MPs. More recently we’ve seen people like Steve Christou and Mark Latham move to the right, although never in the actual Liberal Party.
But Labor has a stronger internal culture and has tended to be hard for outsiders to join. There is a handful of cases of members of progressive minor parties switching to Labor – see Tammy Tyrrell, Dorinda Cox, Cheryl Kernot and Peter Breen – but not actual ex-Liberals. It is interesting that two of those four examples have come during the current parliamentary term.
There is also a lengthy history of ex-Coalition independents working with Labor governments in parliament and Labor giving them a nudge at election time. If Raffoul had announced she was running as an independent in Epping with Labor giving her preferences, that would have been a story but well within the norms. But Raffoul actually joining Labor and running as their endorsed candidate is entirely unprecedented.
I cannot find a single case of someone elected as a Liberal politician then joining Labor and becoming a Labor candidate – please let me know if you find one.
But this also reflects the direction of the Minns government, that was recently described as pursuing a ‘centre-right agenda’. Minns has been vary cautious in pursuing progressive policies and been happy to take conservative positions. Quite recently, he announced that he had made another ‘captain’s call’ to endorse the head of the police union for the seat of Winston Hills.
This may be a clever strategic move, to shift in a conservative direction and pick up ex-Liberal voters looking for a new political home, but it would be quite a shift and would leave parts of the Labor base potentially looking elsewhere too. Right now we are seeing Ben Carroll’s efforts to move in a conservative direction blow. up in his face in Victoria – for now, Chris Minns is doing better than Carroll, but he is moving into uncharted territory.


Ben,
was that link supposed to take us to your other brief or just to the website.
Good post – thanks.
I think NSW has a more centrist political discourse alongside stronger moderate control for NSW Liberals whereas right faction tends to control NSW Labor so there is much less incentive to build a loyal voter base than in other states.
Great post Ben.
Why wouldn’t you target Epping if you were Labor? all of the lower margin targets saw the Liberal incumbents cut and run. They money that would have been spent in Ryde, Oatley et al can go on a seat higher up the target list. I think of the seats you have mentioned – Antony Roberts in Lane Cove is the only one who hasn’t abandoned his post – yet.
Whether it works or not remains to be seen. The good Lebanese volk may vote for one of their own/ or they may take out the Fed Govt property tax changes on the nearest available Labor govt. How many traction does a vote for Minns is a vote for Albo campaign have?
The conservatism point – assuming a healthy re-election for Labor is this the time that some seats start getting turned over from the Right to the Left factions. It happened with Barton in the last Federal election – its only a matter of time till it translates to the State level. if that does happen Minns may be the last of his faction – see QLD ALP.
Very interesting read. Before I read this, I did see Epping being a potential Labor pick up. Based on federal election results, Labor over performed in the overlapping federal electorates. Also, the suburbs north of the M2 i.e Beecroft, Cheltenham and North Epping, are quite teal-ish.
I can see an anti-One Nation campaign resonating in marginal Liberal seats with large CALD communities like Winston Hills and Oatley. The state Liberals built up strong bases over many years and the difference between federal and state results is like night and day.
Labor is short of a majority and might even lose seats to One Nation in Western Sydney (Penrith or Camden) or in the regions. I’m sure that to cover the potential losses, Labor will heavily target various marginal Liberal seats in metro Sydney.