ALP 13.4%
Incumbent MP
Melissa Horne, since 2018.
Geography
Western Melbourne. Williamstown covers areas near Port Phillip Bay to the west of the Melbourne CBD. Williamstown covers most of Hobsons Bay council area and a small southern part of the City of Maribyrnong, covering the suburbs of Altona, Altona North, Brooklyn, Newport, Seaholme, South Kingsville, Spotswood, Williamstown and Williamstown North.
History
Williamstown has existed as an electoral district in the Victorian Legislative Assembly since the Assembly first sat in 1856. It has been held by the ALP continuously for over a century. In recent decades the seat has been held by two Labor Premiers.
The seat was held by a series of unaffiliated members of Parliament in the 19th century before the development of the modern political party. The seat’s MP, William Carter, became a member of the Labor Party in 1891, holding the seat until 1894.
Williamstown was won in 1894 by James Styles as a Labor member. He held the seat until 1900. He later served as a Protectionist Senator from 1901 until his defeat in 1906.
Liberal MP Alexander Ramsay held the seat for two terms from 1900 to 1904, when the Labor Party’s John Lemmon regained the seat. Lemmon held the seat for over half a century, retiring in 1955. William Floyd held the seat from 1955 until 1973. Gordon Stirling held the seat from 1973 until 1988.
Williamstown was won in 1988 by Joan Kirner, a Labor government minister who had been an MLC for Melbourne West province since 1982. Kirner became Premier of Victoria in 1990, and served in the role until her defeat at the 1992 election. She held the seat of Williamstown until her resignation in 1994.
The 1994 by-election was won by Steve Bracks, who had previously served as an advisor to Premiers John Cain and Joan Kirner. Bracks quickly moved to the Opposition frontbench, becoming Shadow Treasurer in 1996. He was elected Labor leader in early 1999 and unexpectedly won the 1999 election, forming a minority government with the support of independent MPs. Bracks won a second term in 2002 and a third in 2006. Bracks resigned as Premier and Member for Williamstown in July 2007.
The 2007 Williamstown by-election was won by Labor candidate Wade Noonan. Noonan was re-elected in 2010 and 2014.
Noonan retired in 2018, and was succeeded by Labor candidate Melissa Horne. Horne was re-elected in 2022.
Assessment
Labor has a large margin here and should be okay.
| Candidate | Party | Votes | % | Swing |
| Melissa Horne | Labor | 16,173 | 41.5 | -8.2 |
| Daria Kellander | Liberal | 10,928 | 28.0 | +7.7 |
| Suzette Rodoreda | Greens | 6,013 | 15.4 | +2.1 |
| Rochelle Fisher | Democratic Labour | 1,632 | 4.2 | +4.2 |
| Julien Q. Macandili | Victorian Socialists | 1,528 | 3.9 | +3.9 |
| Patricia Mackevicius | Animal Justice | 1,049 | 2.7 | +0.5 |
| Alexander Ansalone | Freedom Party | 976 | 2.5 | +2.5 |
| Joshua Mosely | Family First | 675 | 1.7 | +1.7 |
| Informal | 1,878 | 4.6 |
2022 two-party-preferred result
| Candidate | Party | Votes | % | Swing |
| Melissa Horne | Labor | 24,726 | 63.4 | -6.5 |
| Daria Kellander | Liberal | 14,248 | 36.6 | +6.5 |
Booths have been divided into three areas: north-east, south-east and west.
Labor won a majority of the two-party-preferred vote in all three areas, ranging from 62.8% in the south-east to 67.1% in the north-east.
The Greens came third, with a primary vote ranging from 14.3% in the west to 21.5% in the north-east.
| Voter group | GRN prim | ALP 2PP | Total votes | % of votes |
| West | 14.3 | 63.7 | 5,842 | 15.0 |
| North-East | 21.5 | 67.1 | 4,255 | 10.9 |
| South-East | 18.7 | 62.8 | 3,615 | 9.3 |
| Pre-poll | 13.6 | 61.6 | 20,315 | 52.0 |
| Other votes | 16.3 | 61.6 | 5,038 | 12.9 |
Election results in Williamstown at the 2022 Victorian state election
Toggle between two-party-preferred votes and primary votes for Labor, the Liberal Party and the Greens.
This seat has gone under some serious gentrification and it could end up being a three way horse race where the Greens and Liberals both improve.
The Kingsville South booth ttp doesn’t look correct, I can’t see the ttp being 52.3/47.8 where Labor gets a primary vote of 42.7%, Greens get 22.2% and Liberals get 21.4%. The ttp should more be like 66.9%/33.1% or something like that.
The opening of the westgate tunnel might worsen the already bad air quality here and induce increased heavy vehicle traffic on local roads (moreso in Footscray next door I think but still), could be ripe for the right IND to exploit, Liberal primary might be inflated due to a popular local councillor running last time.
A Teal could win here if it becomes a ALP V TEAL contest. Last time there were Anti-Lockdown swings in Altona North the working class parts. I think that will reverse a bit. In the Federal election this seat especially poorer areas had a big swing to Labor. There were also swings around Maddox Road due to Level Crossing controversy.
I dont think Gentrification will benefit the current direction of the Libs as this seat is very Secular.
Tony Briffa’s entry into this race as an independent is interesting. Endorsed by the Voices of Williamstown Electorate group.
There’s a few signs for Briffa going up around the electorate which probably outnumbers those of the other parties at this stage. Briffa is a well known identity in the electorate, having served on the Hobsons Bay Council for several terms including a couple of Mayoral terms.
But other than yard signs, I’m not seeing much activity or mobilisation efforts; which is weird because looking at Briffa’s website and her minimal social media output, she’s clearly spent money on having professional quality assets produced and branding done, including the yard signs, which rivals in quality to some of the bigger ‘teal’ campaigns in the eastern suburbs and isn’t AI slop. This is also in contrast to Jess Marsh, the independent running in neighbouring Footscray, who’s running regular events, catch ups, is active on social media, out in the community talking to people, etc. Not saying Briffa isn’t doing this at all, but she’s certainly not advertising it! Running a state election campaign where people vote on brand recognition/party and not individuals, like a council election where people vote for individuals/name recognition won’t help Briffa’s chances.
Briffa will probably attract some of the flailing Labor vote looking for alternatives to the major parties but very likely not enough to win, but hey this is going to be one of the most bizarre elections in living memory so anything could happen really. Most likely though she’ll garner ~8-10% of the vote and beat the Greens into third place.
Been a bit of a tit for tat between the independent and the Liberal candidate over the long weekend; which started with Briffa’s signage apparently being removed and replaced with Lindemann/Liberal signage (and his signage is all over the place in high visibility spots) in collusion with Lindemann’s real estate agent mates, without consent or knowledge of rental tenants or home owners.
Lindemann then found that the long-deceased former wife of Briffa’s current wife was posting comments on Facebook and liking comments critical of Lindemann in relation to the above, and supposedly posted an image of the deceased’s death certificate (a potential criminal matter) in response to one of these comments. Lindemann hasn’t addressed the validity of these claims made by Briffa’s campaign.
The issue of the deceased ‘coming back from the dead’ made its way to the Council Watch VIC Facebook page, likely via Lindemann himself; where he and his supporters were very quick to jump into the comments feigning concern and replying to nearly every comment making themselves the person of reason, ‘I’m just concerned, we need integrity’, etc. There were definitely quite a few nasty responses in the comments section directed at Briffa too targeting both her intersex status and Briffa’s wife who is undergoing treatment for a brain tumour. Briffa addressed the matter publicly a couple days after this was publicised, admitting that Briffa’s wife had made a mistake in posting from the deceased’s account. People outside of the Council Watch VIC comment section have been pretty outraged at Lindemann.
So yeah, tl;dr: Liberal signage installed without tenants and property owners knowledge, people rising from the dead to support the independent and Liberals (allegedly) illegally obtaining and posting a photo of a deceased person’s death certificate to attack the independent. Given the Liberals are kicking up mud at the independent, I revise my estimate and actually think she’ll get within 15-20% and could very well make the top 2.
Primary vote totals will probably go something like:
Labor: 20-25%
Liberal: 20-25%
Ind (Briffa): 15-20%
Greens: 10-15%
One Nation: ~5%
Victorian Socialists: ~5%
West Party: ~5%
Which on my admittedly rudimentary calculations would result in an Ind-Liberal 2CP of 53-47 in favour of the independent, as both Greens and Labor prefs will overwhelmingly favour the independent over the Liberal.
Tony Briffa’s website is distinctly odd. The fundraising part hits you straight in the eye when you enter. There is a lot of “what I have stood for in the past” and no “this is what I want to do” – no campaign commitments nothing. There is a bit of “you know me, so trust me in future”. Might be just me but it seems a tad complacent.
Had a good wander around this electorate today (Williamstown and Newport) and Lindemann is everywhere, lots of businesses on the shopping strips displaying large coreflutes, some residences as well in the back streets. Some for Labor, Greens and Socialists too, this seat hasn’t come within a 10% since the war but could be one to watch on the night
@ElectionWatcher: Why do you think Labor rather than the Liberals will finish third under your primary vote figures?
If Labor lose a third of their vote here – as suggested by the statewide polls – they could be in real trouble. Very hard to see the Liberals winning though similar type shocks happened in NSW in 2011. A lot will depend on where Briffa and West Party direct their preferences. Not inconceivable that there could be a Greens vs Libs final 2.
For what it’s worth: a reliable source I know within the Greens is saying that they are conceding, based on their own polling, that they won’t win Williamstown.
Greens and socialists combined are tracking for a combined 20% of the primary vote, Labor’s primary vote has collapsed to around the mid 20’s, Liberal and One Nation combined are tracking at around 30-35% of the primary vote, and Briffa is on track to make the top 2 (with around 20% of the primary vote.)
@Joseph – simply because Labor’s vote will be smashed in general, as it will across the state, and with both the Greens and a prominent centre-left independent in the mix that’s going to be amplified. Meanwhile, the Liberals will gain from some of the anti Labor swing; as will ON, which will likely bump up the Libs through preferences.
This combined makes a Liberal vs independent, or Liberal vs Greens, final 2 more likely than a Labor vs independent, or Labor vs Liberal, final 2.
So the direction of West Party preferences could be decisive in terms of who would make the 2CP count here, I’d imagine Briffa would get preferences from across the board no matter who was distributed first? But sounds as if the Liberals have a decent chance of leading on primary at least
Liberal candidate disendorsed after racist social media posts. One down … will there be more?
ON – 1, Lib – 1 in disendorsement stakes.
Lindemann’s disendorsement probably pushes One Nation into the final 2 now as a lot of (but certainly not all) would be Liberal voters will jump over to One Nation, with whichever candidate; whether Greens, Briffa, Labor or even West Party being the other in final pairing, going on to win the seat.
I reckon the Greens will likely finish in the final two. This is thanks to angry/disaffected Labor voters (who won’t swing to the Liberals or One Nation) as well as preferences from Victorian Socialists. I expect massive swings away from both Labor and the Liberals. This means that the count could get messy with a number of candidates potentially getting >10% on primary votes.
I am a bit skeptical of the West Party’s chances in Williamstown and Footscray. They aim to appeal to disaffected voters and western suburbanites who feel left behind. They centre their campaigns on government service delivery and infrastructure.
Both Williamstown and Footscray are gentrifying and have a well-educated, upper-middle income population, less so in Altona and Altona North. They are also close to the CBD and have strong transport links. The West Party may not appeal to them as they would in seats further west. In seats to the north and west, there is more mortgage stress, incomes are lower and infrastructure is a hot-button issue.
@ElectionWatcher: I don’t think the Liberal candidate’s disendorsement will push One Nation into the final two in a socially progressive seat like Williamstown. This seat literally represents One Nation’s worst demographic. Most would-be Liberal voters here won’t be rushing to vote One Nation.
Williamstown is a socially progressive, highly-educated and wealthy electorate dominated by upper-middle-class families in white-collar occupations, which is One Nation’s worst demographic. All but one booth in Williamstown voted Yes in the 2023 Voice Referendum, with many booths recording overwhelming Yes majorities. Would-be Liberal voters in the electorate tend to be white-collar professionals with university degrees earning high incomes, many of whom voted Yes to the Voice. This means would-be Liberal voters here are more likely to be moderate rather than conservative and would not countenance preferencing One Nation, let along voting for it. For this reason I don’t think One Nation will make the final two.
For moderate Liberal voters in Williamstown, independent Tony Briffa or the West Party are the most palatable alternative options for them.
The West Party probably won’t get much momentum here. The West Party centre their campaigns on government service delivery and infrastructure. Such campiagns will have much less appeal in seats like Williamstown and Footscray with upper-middle class populations that are close to the CBD and have strong transport links than in seats further West with much poorer infrastructure and lower incomes.
I think independent Tony Briffa is the favourite to make the 2CP against Labor, as she will attract disaffected Labor voters who won’t switch to the Liberals, One Nation or the Greens as well as disaffected Liberal voters who won’t switch to One Nation, whereas the Greens will only attract disaffected Labor voters. Briffa herself could take some votes from the Greens. Preferences from the Liberals and One Nation could also push Briffa ahead of the Greens. The count could get really messy with four candidates (Greens, Briffa, Liberals and One Nation) potentially polling between 10% and 20%, making it really difficult to figure out who will finish second without a distribution of preferences.
@Joseph The reason I suggest One Nation would probably make the top 2 now that the Liberal campaign has been shot dead is because the Altona cluster of suburbs within the electorate are very white/European/anglo working class compared to the Williamstown cluster of suburbs which are higher income and have a more highly educational demographic (but still very white/anglo). One Nation won’t do well in the latter but would notionally have some appeal in the former.
Briffa’s main name recognition is in the Altona cluster of suburbs though which could mute One Nation’s appeal, while the demographic of the Williamstown cluster of suburbs favours a ‘teal’ independent which will come at the expense of Labor’s (which as mentioned earlier is going to be smashed in this election) and the Greens’ vote mostly, same as similar independents in the inner eastern suburbs.
@ Votante/Election Watcher
I would seperate Altona from Altona North and Altona Meadows from a demographic perpective. I would actually say Altona itself is increasingly affluent and gentrifying although not to the extent as Williamstown. It is more like the Sandbelt suburbs. This is due to Altona being one of the only two beaches in the Western suburbs along with Williamstown as Melbourne has grown the amount of beachfront land so this scarcity as led to gentrification. Altona is better educated than average it is also Whiter so i feel it is increasingly a White professional suburb like Mordiallic so ONP will not do well there.
Altona Meadows is White working class with large Maltese and Italian communities, lower levels of education, more Christian and hence will be good for ONP but that is in the seat of Point Cook. Altona North is inland and the only working class area in this seat. However, it is about 16% Muslim and really the only diverse part of this seat. Hobsons Bay LGA is actually getting less diverse over time as it is gentifying and does not really have growth areas that can attract migrants
https://profile.id.com.au/hobsons-bay/language?EndYear=2001&DataType=UR
*amount of beachfront land remains the same. Altona also has higher property prices than Melbourne average
@Nimalan, I agree that Altona is gentrifying as it has beachfront. Lots of white collar professionals have moved in as it deindustrialised.
I think there could be many former loyal Labor voters who will swing to One Nation. They may be religious, working class voters who have lived in Altona and Altona North since the manufacturing heyday but no longer work in manufacturing. Many of them may see One Nation as protectionist and socially conservative and as the antidote of deindustrialisition and globalisation.
Agree Votante
There maybe still Legacy older working class voters in Altona itself while more younger residents are white collar. There used to be the old Toyota factory and there used to be an Oil Refinery so One Nation Protectionism Self-Sufficency message could resonate there. I feel this area is close to Kingsford Smith/Maroubra area demographically.
This is one electorate where the old Labor base meets the new Labor base. It is like Wallsend in NSW. The east is gentrifying with white collar professionals moving in whilst the west has traditional, blue collar Labor voters.
@Nimalan, I agree it is a bit like Maroubra or Kingsford Smith. Proximity to the water and a port encouraged manufacturing to grow in the first place.
Altona and Altona North used to have petrochemicals manufacturing and food processing as well as Toyota.
@Vontante, agree this seat alongside Wallsend as well as the Federal Seat of Corio, Cunningham and Newcastle are considered where ‘Old and New School Labor Voters meet’
@ Marh/Votante
I would also add the Federal seat of Fremantle and Adelaide as where Old and New School Labor voters meet. These seats can be identified as they narrowly voted Yes or narrowly voted No to the voice and in many cases the Voice result was actually slightly better or just slightly worse than the Republic when adjusted to 2022 boundaries.
The Federal seat of Fraser is also in the process of gentrification and is less gentrified than Cooper or Wills. In all of these cases the long term trejectory benefits the Progressive side of politics as there will be less Red One Nation voters over time or DLP style (Economically Left, Socially Right)
Reports in the media saying Lindemann’s continuing his campaign as an independent. He’d be lucky if his personal vote carries 10% of the vote, if that, without the Liberal brand behind him (even with him on the ballot as a Liberal). ‘Brand Liberal’ probably carries 20-25% of a rump vote.