Ryde council election, 2021

Ryde council covers the inner north-west of Sydney, covering suburbs at the western end of the lower north shore on the north side of the Parramatta River. The council covers the suburbs of Ryde, Meadowbank, West Ryde, Denistone, Melrose Park, Eastwood, Marsfield, Macquarie Park, North Ryde and parts of Gladesville.

The council has a population of about 131,000 as of 2019.

Wards
The City of Ryde is divided into three wards, with each ward electing four councillors.

East ward covers Putney, Gladesville, North Ryde and East Ryde.

Central ward covers Ryde, Meadowbank and parts of West Ryde and Macquarie Park.

West ward covers the remainder of West Ryde and Macquarie Park, as well as Eastwood, Denistone, Melrose Park and Marsfield.

Incumbent councillors

Central East West
Edwina Clifton (Greens) Christopher Gordon (Greens) Trenton Brown (Liberal)
Chris Moujalli (Liberal) Jordan Lane (Liberal) Peter Kim (Independent)1
Bernard Purcell (Labor) Roy Maggio (Independent) Jerome Laxale (Labor)
Sarkis Yedelian (Liberal) Penny Pedersen (Labor) Simon Zhou (Independent)

1Kim was suspended from Labor after being elected deputy mayor with Liberal support in 2020.

History
Ryde is an area which has tended to lean towards the Liberal Party, but much less so than other parts of the north shore. Despite this trend, the Liberal Party only began running official candidates in 2008.

Prior to the 2004 election, the mayoralty had been shared around amongst an independent grouping, with Edna Wilde and Ivan Petch each serving two terms as mayor from 1999 until March 2004.

At the 2004 election, Labor won three seats alongside two Greens. The remaining seven seats went to independents, including at least one who later won a seat as a Liberal.

Independent Terry Perram served as mayor from 2004 to 2005, followed by Ivan Petch from 2005 until 2008.

The Liberal Party made its first official push for Ryde council in 2008, winning four seats. Labor also won four seats, with the Greens winning no seats on the council. The remaining four were held by independents.

The mayoralty was shared between the major parties, with Liberal Vic Tagg serving as mayor from 2008 until 2009, followed by Labor’s Michael Butterworth until 2010, and then Liberal councillor Artin Etmekdjian from 2010 until 2012.

The Liberal Party gained ground from Labor in 2012, winning a fifth seat. Labor only won three, while four independents won seats. Three of these independents had served on the previous council.

Independent councillor Ivan Petch served as mayor from 2012 to 2013, followed by Liberal councillor Roy Maggio from 2013 to 2014 and then fellow Liberal Bill Pickering from 2014 to 2015.

Former mayor Ivan Petch resigned in late 2014, triggering an early 2015 by-election won by Liberal candidate Jane Stott. This gave the Liberal Party six out of twelve seats on the council.

Despite this shift in the numbers, the 2015 mayoral election saw Labor’s Jerome Laxale win when the result was drawn from a hat. Former Liberal mayor Etmekdjian won the vote of all six Liberal councillors, while the three current and former Labor councillors voted for Laxale, and the three other independents voted for Terry Perram. Laxale won the tiebreaker between himself and Perram, and Perram’s supporters went on to vote for Laxale, resulting in a 6-6 tie. This result was broken by drawing Laxale’s name out of the hat.

Liberal councillor Bill Pickering returned to the mayoralty in September 2016, thanks to former Labor councillor Jeff Salvestro-Martin switching and supporting Pickering over Labor’s Laxale.

The council swung to the left in 2017. Labor won a fourth seat, while the Greens returned to the council with two seats. The Liberal Party was reduced to four seats, along with two independents.

Jerome Laxale has held the mayoralty since 2017. Labor and Greens have generally voted together on leadership elections, while independent Simon Zhou has either voted with them or abstained.

Greens councillor Chris Gordon was elected deputy mayor in 2017, while Zhou took the job in 2018 and 2019.

Labor councillor Peter Kim nominated for deputy mayor in 2020 with the support of the Liberal councillors and Maggio, resulting in a 6-6 tie against Greens councillor Gordon. Kim won the draw of the hat, and was subsequently suspended by the ALP.

Candidate summary
Labor and Liberal are running full tickets. All three incumbent Labor councillors are running for re-election. Three out of four Liberals are running for re-election.

One of the two Greens elected in 2017 is running again, with a new candidate in one other ward.

The three incumbent independents are all running for re-election, with three other groups also running.

The full candidate list is at the end of this guide.

Assessment
Labor has had a working majority for the last four years, but that is not typical for Ryde.

Labor and the Liberal Party each have three safe seats. A party needs about 40% after preferences to win a second seat in a ward. A number of candidates were elected with a primary vote of 11-13%. The second Liberal councillor in the East was elected with 11%, as did independent councillor Zhou in the West. The Greens councillor in the East won with less than 14%.

So there are a number of seats that could well be in play. A flip of just one seat from the left to the right would be enough to tie the council.

2017 results

PartyVotes%SwingSeats won
Liberal 17,62731.45-2.94
Labor 17,19230.68+14.54
Independents12,10521.60-11.72
Greens 5,5209.85-0.62
Christian Democrats3,5966.42-0.9
Informal3,4905.86

Vote breakdown by ward
The Liberal Party topped the poll in two wards, with a vote ranging from 30.2% in the west ward to 33.0% in the central ward. The Liberal Party won two seats in the central ward and one each in the other wards.

Labor’s vote was much more widely varied, ranging from 23.8% in the east ward to 39.6% in the west ward. Labor won two seats in the west ward and one each in the other two wards.

Independents ran in all three wards. Two groups ran in the east ward, with Roy Maggio polling 21.8% and the other group polling 9%. Simon Zhou’s group polled 13% in the west ward, with 8% for a different independent group. The sole independent group in the central ward polled 12%.

The Greens ran in two wards, winning a seat in each ward. Their vote was 13.6% in the east and 15.9% in the central ward.

WardLIB %ALP %IND %GRN %
Central33.028.711.915.9
East31.123.831.413.6
West30.239.621.30.0

Election results at the 2017 City of Ryde election
Toggle between primary votes for the Liberal Party, Labor, independent candidates and the Greens.

Candidates – Central

  • A – Labor
    1. Cr Bernard Purcell
    2. Katie O’Reilly
    3. Francisco Valencia Cepeda
    4. Margaret Mayger
  • B – Independent
    1. Felix Lo
    2. Lisa Liu
    3. Benedict Lau
    4. Steven Dearing
  • C – Independent
    1. Gaurav Patni
    2. Jordan Hodgson
    3. Amrita Narain
    4. Vishal Singal
  • D – Liberal
    1. Cr Sarkis Yedelian
    2. Shweta Deshpande
    3. Antonia Courtelis
    4. Granville Schokman
  • E – Greens
    1. Cosmin Luca
    2. Harpreet Dhillon
    3. Jonathan Brough
    4. Catherine Rytmeister

Candidates – East

  • A – Labor
    1. Cr Penny Pederson
    2. Eloise Price
    3. James Jelly
    4. Chris Rutter
  • B – Independent
    1. Cr Roy Maggio
    2. Crystal Tisseverasinghe
    3. Louis George
    4. Marianinna Candy
  • C – Liberal
    1. Cr Jordan Lane
    2. Sophie Lara-Watson
    3. Sarah McFayden
    4. Christopher Galloway
  • D – Greens
    1. Cr Christopher Gordon
    2. Helena Malinowska
    3. David Isaacs
    4. Yaser Naseri

Candidates – West

  • A – Independent
    1. Cr Peter Kim
    2. Lichen Zhang
    3. Michael Melville
    4. May Mak
  • B – Labor
    1. Cr Jerome Laxale
    2. Charles Song
    3. Jananie Janarthana
    4. Steve Colquhoun
  • C – Independent
    1. Bin Lin
    2. Leanne Zullo
    3. Wai Yeung
    4. Xiaogang Zhang
  • D – Liberal
    1. Cr Trenton Brown
    2. Daniel Han
    3. Timothy Pinzone
    4. Elaine Budd
  • E – Independent
    1. Cr Simon Zhou
    2. Hugh Lee
    3. Katherine Prosser
    4. Rain Song

Become a Patron!

14 COMMENTS

  1. Labor will lose power in this council area, Liberal minority (possibly only 1 or 2 seats short) I see the independents backing them to unseat the Labor/Green council government

    This is Bennelong federally and with Labor on the nose statewide and federally and Covid isn’t helping their case I expect if the Liberal party are gaining councils this will be one of the first ones to flip. Parramatta is already blue so it is strange seeing this have a Labor controlled government.

    LIB (Minority) takeover

  2. Edwina Clifton defected from Greens to Labor (I think in 2019). It’s going to be hard to keep track of all these things though

  3. Yes and then she switched back to the Greens. She was a Greens candidate when I compiled the list of local councillors, although she has since been deselected.

  4. yes it is very close to Bennelong boundaries…. but that does not mean the libs will win. look at the difference in tas votes at different levels of govt. This area is better described as liberal leaning which can swing massively up to 10%.

  5. The current culture in the Ryde Council is extremely toxic and partisan, largely perpetuated by Mayor Jerome. It’s time the community threw their support behind new local Independents who can bring a positive change.

  6. Clifton went from Green to Labor and now independent (but still loyal to Mayor Laxale, ALP). Labor will lose one in West Ward with ex-ALP Peter Kim being expelled. The September 2021 Mayoral & Deputy election at 6 aside (out of a hat) will be critical for The Greens Christopher Gordon (East Ward)) future in the lead up to the December 2021 council elections.

    Too close to call, too many variables still in play.

  7. All over in Ryde now bar the actual election, campaign and counting of votes. ALP Mayor Jerome Laxale to be easily re-elected as Mayor following the 4 December 2021 election.

    All doubts removed on 28 Sept 2021 when one time Lib Mayor Roy Maggio (ousted from the Libs in 2017) abstained from the 66 day Mayoral election to give ALP Mayor Laxale the numbers for re-election. In the Libs strongest (East) ward there is now 1 Lib, 1 ALP, 1 Green & Maggio (Indep). Minor changes only of councilors expected on 4 Dec 2021.

  8. With former Lib Mayor Roy Maggio (and cousin of state MP Victor Dominello) not supporting the Libs in East Ward and unlikely to pass surplus votes to Libs on 4 December it is hard to see Libs getting a second councillor in East Ward. Without that the Libs have no chance of unseating ALP Mayor Laxale who will be supported by the Greens and ex-ALP candidates running as Independents.

  9. According to the brochure dropped in my letterbox, the web site for the Liberal candidates for Ryde is:
    http://www.rydeliberals.com
    The same address can be found on NSW electoral commission web site. Click on any of the “Show” links on
    https://www.elections.nsw.gov.au/Elections/Local-government-elections/Local-Government-Elections-2021/Candidates/Ryde/West%20Ward/291

    Tried that address address today and it’s dead. Firefox gives: “We can’t connect to the server at http://www.rydeliberals.com.” (Precise wording of error will vary by browser.)

    Curiously, rydeliberals.com (without the “www.” prefix) does work, so someone has made a fairly basic error when configuring their web site, an error which is usually easily fixed.

    In West Ward, does anyone know anything about Group C or Group E? I’ve been searching for their names on the web, but it’s as if these people have no web presence at all. The only exception seems to be the 4th candidate in Group E, who has an uncommon name, so is probably the person mentioned in the following.

    https://www.smh.com.au/business/banking-and-finance/nab-lender-fairly-sacked-over-fake-loan-referrals-20190330-p5195d.html

  10. Spoken to a volunteer that handed out leaflets for Group C (Dr Bin Lin).
    It appears that Dr Bin Lin has been a Chinese language teacher for more than 15 years in Eastwood, and a radio host for 2CR Radio (Sydney), also has a Youtube channel discussing current affairs, however in Cantonese.
    His leaflet indicated that he promotes fairness, all voices to be heard instead of only consult so called community groups for feedback.

    Group E – You only need to google “Simon Zhou Ryde” to see all the negative news showing up…

  11. I’ve lived in East Ward for years and am definitely NOT a partisan voter, but I have to give a free plug for Penny Pederson here as I’ve seen her in action on numerous occasions in my capacity as a Ryde community (not political) volunteer. In the council meetings run by Penny where volunteers have been offered the chance to take part, I have witnessed Penny being utterly professional, efficient, respectful and logical. She instigates great initiatives and then gets them implemented, and she definitely has the whole Ryde community in mind when she makes decisions. While many people in all levels of politics have languished for years in their attitudes and responses to climate change and the environment, Penny has pushed initiatives like EV charging stations, tree planting, pollution control and improvements to parkland and other green spaces for the benefit of all. Just saying…..in case you know nothing about her.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here