Archive for March, 2010

South Australia 2010: predictions

Following yesterday’s prediction of the results in Saturday’s Tasmanian election, I have now put together a prediction of the result in South Australia. I haven’t followed South Australia as closely as I have with Tasmania, so I have mostly made the changes based on the pendulum. The hardest choices were for the seats of Chaffey and Mitchell. I’ve predicted that Mitchell’s incumbency should allow him to overcome difficult circumstances. In contrast, I’m predicting that Nationals MP Karlene Maywald will be brought down by her connection to the Rann government in a conservative rural electorate. In addition, I have predicted that the ALP will lose Light, Mawson, Norwood, Newland and Morialta. I also have put Mount Gambier as a Liberal gain, due to the retirement of sitting independent MP Rory McEwen.

This would produce a result of 23 Labor, 21 Liberal and 3 independents. This would reflect the pattern of the 1989, 1997 and 2002 elections when no party managed a majority and independents supported the larger minority. On these numbers the ALP would probably scrape by, but would be vulnerable to by-elections or defections.

I have posted two maps showing how this changes the electoral map. The seven seat gains are coloured in light blue to distinguish them from the seats held by the Liberals already.

Greater Adelaide area.

South-eastern parts of South Australia. Chaffey and Mount Gambier can be seen on the eastern border of the state in light blue.

Tasmania 2010: predictions

I have previously made predictions of election results for a number of elections, including Queensland in 2009 and elections for the ACT, Canada and the United States in 2008. I thought it was about time to post predictions for this weekend’s elections in Tasmania and South Australia. I will post my prediction for South Australia tomorrow, along with maps showing how this would look. As for Tasmania, my overall prediction is:

  • Liberal – 10 (+3)
  • Labor – 9 (-5)
  • Greens – 6 (+2)

This would produce a hung parliament with the Greens determining which party forms government. This prediction would involve the Liberals and Labor winning two seats each in Bass, Braddon, Franklin and Lyons, with the Liberals and Greens winning two seats each in Denison.

Full predictions (including non-core predictions of individual winners) after the fold. I encourage readers to post their own predictions.

Elsewhere predictions have been made by Peter Tucker and Kevin Bonham.

Read the rest of this entry »

Seat profile #73: Newcastle

The seat of Newcastle covers most of the city of Newcastle and surrounding areas. It is an original federation electorate and is the only seat to have been held by the Labor Party since 1901.It is a solidly safe seat for the ALP, although it has a strong history for the Greens, particularly in local government. It has been held by Labor MP Sharon Grierson since 2001, and she is very likely to win re-election in 2010.

Continue reading…

Seat profile #72: Casey

Casey is a marginal Liberal seat on the eastern fringe of Melbourne. Casey covers parts of the Yarra Ranges and Dandenong Ranges as well as Melbourne suburbs such as Croydon. While Casey has a history of being a bellwether seat, the seat has been held by the Liberal Party since 1984. It has previously been held by Bob Halverson, Speaker of the House of Representatives in the Howard government’s first term, and Michael Wooldridge, John Howard’s Health Minister who transferred from a neighbouring seat in 1998. The seat has been held by Liberal frontbencher Tony Smith since 2001, and is held by a 5.9% margin.

Continue reading…

Tasmanian poll: Greens outpoll Labor

Another EMRS poll has been released over the weekend in Tasmania, which reinforces the trend seen in a February poll towards record levels of support for the Tasmanian Greens.

While it appears that the full breakdown of results has not been published online (only appearing in the Examiner), the topline figures are:

  • 29 – Liberal
  • 22 – Greens
  • 21 – Labor
  • 2 – Others
  • 26 – Undecided

All EMRS polls are published with high levels of undecided voters, meaning that these numbers would be much higher once those are taken into account, and undecided voters usually favour the major parties over the Greens, particularly that major party with the best shot of majority government, although on the current numbers that doesn’t seem likely at all.

The poll also broke down votes according to each electorate. Samples are usually too small to take them seriously, although much has been made of the Denison poll predicting that Scott Bacon, son of the former premier, would possibly take the only ALP seat, beating out Premier David Bartlett and ministers Lisa Singh and Graeme Sturges, showing the importance of name recognition in Tasmanian politics.

Since the last two polls were very similar, Tasmanian psephologist Kevin Bonham has combined the electorate breakdowns to produce a more solid sample. These figures suggest that the Greens are solidly on track to win 6 seats (one in every district and two in Denison) and even outpolling the ALP in Franklin, which could suggest Adam Burling would have an outside chance of winning a second Greens seat in Franklin, although he doesn’t have a high profile.

In other news, four former premiers (two Labor, two Liberal) have come out to warn Tasmanians against a minority government, although at this point it doesn’t seem clear how Tasmanians could vote to avoid a hung parliament. Peter Tucker has commented on this panic-stricken move at his Tasmanian Politics blog.

Update: William Bowe has managed to track down more information about this elusive poll over at Poll Bludger. After including “leaners” the figures come out as:

  • 30 – Liberal
  • 23 – Labor
  • 22 – Greens
  • “almost a quarter” undecided

Which he interprets as 39 Liberal, 30 Labor, 29 Greens. Compared to the February poll, this has the undecided vote up a large amount (from 13% to 23-4%), with Liberals down four, Labor down four, and the Greens down two.

Seat profile #71: Reid

Reid is a safe Labor seat in inner-western Sydney. It has been created by the effective merger of the seats of Lowe and Reid. The seat covers a majority of the former seat of Lowe as well as parts of the former seat of Reid.

The seat covers Auburn, Concord and Drummoyne and parts of Burwood and Strathfield. The seat of Reid is held by Labor MP Laurie Ferguson, and the seat of Lowe is held by Labor MP John Murphy, although Murphy will be contesting the seat in 2010, with Ferguson moving to another seat.

Continue reading…

Seat profile #70: Aston

Aston is a marginal Liberal seat lying on the mortgage belt in Melbourne’s eastern suburbs. The seat has usually elected Liberal MPs by slim margins, and was the setting for a key by-election in 2001 where the Howard government blunted the anti-Liberal swing and began their recovery that saw them re-elected later that year. The seat has been held since that by-election by Liberal MP Chris Pearce, who is retiring at the upcoming election.

Continue reading…

Seat profile #69: Banks

Banks is a Labor seat covering Hurstville and surrounding areas in southern Sydney. While it has been a seat based on southern Bankstown in the past, it has shifted east for this year’s election, with suburbs such as Panania, East Hills and Picnic Point transferred to the neighbouring seat of Hughes. Banks is held by a 9.7% margin, although it was held by a slim 1.06% margin at the 2004 election. It has been held by Labor MP Daryl Melham since 1990.

Continue reading…

Seat profile #68: Wakefield

Wakefield is a seat on the northern fringe of Adelaide, covering the suburbs of Elizabeth and Gawler and rural areas as far north as Clare. The seat has only been won by the ALP three times, and had been held by the Liberal Party continuously from 1946 until the ALP’s Nick Champion won it in 2007. The seat underwent a redistribution in 2004 which moved it into more urban areas on the northern side of Adelaide. The seat is held by the ALP by a 6.6% margin.

Continue reading…

Seat profile #67: Watson

Watson is a safe Labor seat in the inner south-west of Sydney. It covers most of the Canterbury area as well as suburbs around Bankstown, Strathfield and Burwood. The seat has been dramatically redistributed, losing southern parts of Canterbury and parts of the St George area and gaining Burwood and Strathfield areas from the abolished seat of Lowe. The seat has been held by Agriculture Minister Tony Burke since 2004.

Continue reading…