Hume – Election 2010

LIB 5.3%

Incumbent MP
Alby Schultz, since 1998.

Geography
Southern NSW. Hume covers southern NSW from Young and Cootamundra in the west and Cowra in the north, through Yass and Goulburn and up the Hume Highway to cover most of Wollondilly Shire on the southwestern outskirts of Sydney. The seat covers most of the Hume Highway between Sydney and Canberra, although the Southern Highlands towns of Moss Vale, Bowral and Mittagong are not included. While the seat follows the Hume Highway, the exclusion of Bowral and its neighbouring towns isolates Wollondilly from the rest of the seat’s population.

Redistribution
At the redistribution, Hume expanded to the northwest to cover Cowra and Weddin local council areas, and to the southhwest to cover Cootamundra. Hume also expanded to the northeast, taking in most of Wollondilly Shire. In exchange for these expansions, the seat lost much of Wingecarribee Shire east of the Hume Highway, including the towns of Bowral, Berrima, Mittagong and Moss Vale.

History
Hume is an original federation electorate, and originally covered the NSW border region, including the towns of Albury, Gundagai and Cootamundra.

The seat was first won by William Lyne in 1901. Lyne was a Protectionist and had previously been Premier of New South Wales, and a leading opponent of federation.

Lyne had been originally offered the role of Australia’s first Prime Minister by Governor-General Lord Hopetoun, but failed to form a ministry and instead became a minister in Edmund Barton’s first cabinet.

Lyne served in Edmund Barton and Alfred Deakin’s Protectionist cabinets from 1901 to 1904 and 1905 to 1908. Lyne refused to join with Alfred Deakin when the Protectionist and Free Trade parties merged to form the Commonwealth Liberal Party in 1909, and served as an independent until 1913.

Lyne was defeated in 1913 by Commonwealth Liberal Party candidate Robert Patten, who held the seat until his retirement in 1917, when the seat was won by Franc Falkiner (LIB), who had previously held the seat of Riverina from 1913 to 1914. Falkiner abandoned Hume in 1919 in an attempt to move to the Senate.

Parker Moloney (ALP) won Hume in 1919. Moloney had previously held the neighbouring seat of Indi in Victoria from 1910 to 1913 and 1914 to 1917.

Moloney held the seat until 1931, when he was defeated by Thomas Collins of the Country Party. This began a period of Hume being a marginal seat between the ALP and the Country Party until 1974.

Collins was defeated by Arthur Fuller (ALP) in 1943, after serving as a minister in Robert Menzies’ first government.

Fuller was defeated in 1949 by Charles Anderson of the Country Party. Fuller won back the seat in 1951, and Anderson won it back again in 1955. Fuller defeated Anderson for the last time in 1961.

Fuller was defeated by John Pettiitt of the Country Party in 1963. Pettitt held the seat until he was defeated by the ALP’s Frank Olley at the 1972 election. Olley was defeated by Stephen Lusher of the Country Party in 1975. This was the last time the seat was held by the ALP, and the margin for future National and Liberal candidates increased to a safer range.

At the 1984 election, a redistribution saw the Liberal member for Farrer and former Fraser government minister Wal Fife challenge Lusher. Lusher came third and his preferences elected Fife.

Fife held the seat until his retirement at the 1993 election, when a redistribution saw the National member for Gilmore, John Sharp, move to Hume. Sharp served as a minister in the first term of the Howard government before his career was claimed by the travel rorts affair, and he retired in 1998.

The 1998 election saw the seat go to Alby Schultz, previously the Liberal member for the state seat of Burrinjuck since 1988. Schultz came first on primary votes, with the National candidate reduced to fourth place behind One Nation.

The 2000 redistribution saw Hume move into the Southern Highlands, and saw Macarthur move into more marginal territory in south-western Sydney. Finance Minister John Fahey, former NSW premier and member for Macarthur, planned to run for preselection in Hume, into which his home base of the Southern Highlands had been redistributed. Fahey, however, decided to retire due to ill-health, freeing up Schultz to run for re-election.

Schultz has been reelected at every election since then, achieving the largest margin in Hume ever in 2004, with 64.1% of the two-party preferred vote.

Candidates

  • Charles Liptak (Family First)
  • Greg Butler (Democrats)
  • Robin Saville (Labor)
  • Lisa Milat (Liberal Democrats)
  • Kevin Watchirs (Greens)
  • Karen Buttigieg (Christian Democratic Party)
  • Alby Schultz (Liberal)

Political situation
While Hume’s margin has fallen substantially, Schultz has a strong local presence and the Coalition has comfortably held onto the seat in recent years.

2007 result

Candidate Party Votes % Swing
Alby Schultz LIB 41,344 49.18 -7.45
David Grant ALP 31,882 37.93 +8.88
Jim Clark GRN 6,414 7.63 +3.68
Geoff Peet CDP 2,010 2.39 -1.09
Cathy Trent FF 1,958 2.33 +2.33
Lindsay Crosgrove CEC 455 0.54 -0.08

2007 two-candidate-preferred result

Candidate Party Votes % Swing
Alby Schultz LIB 45,526 54.16 -8.68
David Grant ALP 38,537 45.84 +8.68

Results do not take into account effects of the redistribution.

Booth breakdown
I have divided booths in Hume into six areas. Most of these are based on local government areas. I have divided booths in Wingecarribee between those closest to Wollondilly or Goulburn Mulwaree. The central parts of Wingecarribee have been removed from the seat, producing a clear distinction between booths in the LGA.

  • Wollondilly – Wollondilly LGA and northern parts of Wingecarribee LGA.
  • Goulburn – Goulburn Mulwaree LGA and southern parts of Wingecarribee LGA.
  • Upper Lachlann – Boorowa and Upper Lachlan LGAs.
  • Yass – Yass Valley and Palerang LGAs.
  • Cowra – Cowra and Weddin LGAs.
  • Young – Young, Cootamundra and Harden LGAs.
Polling booths in Hume. Goulburn in green, Wollondilly in orange, Upper Lachlan in red, Yass in blue, Young in yellow, Cowra in purple.
Voter group GRN % LIB 2CP % Total votes % of ordinary votes
Wollondilly 6.15 53.35 17,764 26.01
Goulburn 6.93 47.39 15,329 22.45
Young 3.72 58.91 12,256 17.95
Yass 10.58 51.95 9,456 13.85
Cowra 2.42 61.71 8,231 12.05
Upper Lachlan 4.09 62.44 5,258 7.70
Other votes 8.10 56.73 17,302
Polling booths in Hume, showing results of the 2007 election.
Polling booths in Hume, showing results of the 2007 election in Yass and Goulburn.
Polling booths in Hume, showing results of the 2007 election in Goulburn.
Polling booths in Hume, showing results of the 2007 election in Young, Cootamundra and Harden.
Polling booths in Hume, showing results of the 2007 election in Hume.

9 COMMENTS

  1. Labor used to benefit here due to the Irish Catholic population around Cootamundra, but now the ‘cultural left’ electorates are in the inner city rather than the Catholic bush. 1988 state election when Scultz won Burrinjuck was the end of this tradition.

  2. Interesting how the Canberra overflow gives Yass Shire such a high Green vote for a Western NSW seat.

    The Libs are in a bit of a pickle with Hume. Alby Schultz is an ageing backbench-warmer who should be moved on, but his high profile and maverick streak means he’d probably win as an Independent.

  3. Given the Greens radical views on trying to change the planets natural cyclical weather patterns to the detriment of every resident of regional Australia I believe that their showing in Hume will be nothing less than disastrous.

    As the assessment quite clearly states the redistribution has delivered a severe blow to the Liberals, in particular Alby. The Schultz stronghold of the Southern Highlands has been lost and with 65% of the new coalition vote coming from Nationals held seats I doubt that will be to Alby’s advantage. Let’s face it, at every opportunity Alby has derided the Nationals, called for them to be dumped, entertained a very embarrassing heavyweight scuffle over them and even handed out against a Nationals candidate.

    Assuming that Mr Schultz is pre-selected (as yet not confirmed) it would be the height of hypocrisy for him to go cap in hand to the Nats for their support, without which winning would be difficult. We must not forget that the swing against Alby at the 2007 election was approx.9% well above the national average and in some key booths over 16% so I would question his potential success as an independent.

    The key question being will Alby be the Lib candidate. Nominations for Macarthur and Hume were called at the same time last year. Macarthur has been confirmed with the dumping of Pat Farmer but not Hume. Surely this would just be a rubber stamp for Alby; or would it?!! The coalition agreement has yet to be signed, could the Libs be stringing the Nats along?!! Could the Nats challenge?!! Who will be the labor candidate?!! This could turn out to be the most controversial and exciting seat in the Country.

  4. Kevin Watchirs has been preselected to run for the Greens in the 2010 election for Hume. He was also the preselected Greens candidate in 2001.

    Alby Schultz, as expected to run as the Liberals candidate.

    No word on a Labor candidate at all

  5. I have been looking for that information everywhere and only read about the preselection happening this week, I did not realise it had all ready occurred. There is a confirmation of sorts, here.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here